A Comparison of Life Cycle Impact of Mass Timber and Concrete in Building Construction

Table 5.

Comparison of life cycle impacts between differentmaterial groups – Results from Athena impact estimator for buildings(Phases A to D of LCA, excluding operational energy use).

LCA Measures

Material group 1

Material group 2

Material group 3

Material group 1 vs. group 2

Material group 1 vs. group 3

Material group 2 vs. group 3

Global Warming Potential, kg CO2 eq

5.54E+04

1.62E+04

1.83E+04

242%

202%

13%

Acidification Potential, kg SO2 eq

3.31E+02

2.06E+02

2.15E+02

60%

54%

4%

HH Particulate, kg PM2.5 eq

1.00E+02

6.22E+01

6.27E+01

61%

60%

1%

Eutrophication Potential, kg N eq

2.42E+01

1.58E+01

1.62E+01

53%

50%

2%

Ozone Depletion Potential, kg CFC-11 eq

3.96E-04

2.37E-04

2.17E-04

67%

82%

-8%

Smog Potential, kg O3 eq

6.38E+03

4.17E+03

4.27E+03

53%

49%

2%

Total Primary Energy, MJ

9.09E+05

6.87E+05

7.07E+05

32%

29%

3%

Non-Renewable Energy, MJ

8.75E+05

6.17E+05

6.31E+05

42%

39%

2%

Fossil Fuel Consumption, MJ

8.12E+05

5.89E+05

6.02E+05

38%

35%

2%