Back to Article
Effectiveness and Safety of Acupuncture Combined with Bloodletting Cupping Therapy in the Treatment of Scapulohumeral Periarthritis: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
World Journal of Clinical Medicine Research
| Vol 5, Issue 1
Table 1. Characteristics of the included studies
| Included studies | Participants (Experimental group/Control group) | Intervention | Duation (days) | Age (year) | Outcome | |
| Experimental group | Control group | |||||
| Chen 2009 [11] | 30/28 | Pricking cupping +A | A | 60 | T:52±1.56 C:53±1.25 | ①② |
| Zhang 2010 [12] | 60/60 | Pricking cupping +B | B | 20 | T:— C:— | ① |
| Li 2014 [13] | 60/60 | Pricking cupping +A | A | 28 | 43-61 | ① |
| Chen 2015 [14] | 38/38 | Pricking cupping +B | B | 28 | T:51.28±7.23 C:53.13±6.35 | ①② |
| Zheng 2015 [15] | 30/30 | Pricking cupping +B | B | 28 | T:54.50±5.01 C:54.23±5.84 | ①② |
| Jiang 2016 [16] | 60/60 | Pricking cupping +B | B | 20 | T:— C:— | ① |
| Huang 2017 [17] | 26/26 | Pricking cupping +B | B | 12 | T:53.1±5.5 C:52.6±5.6 | ① |
| Wang 2018 [18] | 39/39 | Pricking cupping+C | C | 4 | T:53.36±7.25 C:52.20±8.39 | ①④ |
| Nie 2018 [19] | 30/30 | Pricking cupping+D | D | 14 | T:48.20±4.397 C:48.30±4.170 | ①②③ |
| Huang 2019 [20] | 39/37 | Pricking cupping +B | B | 20 | T:52.81±7.84 C:53.16±8.23 | ① |
| Liu 2019 [21] | 42/42 | Pricking cupping+C | C | 20 | T:52.46±4.17 C:53.18±3.96 | ① |
| Zhang 2020 [22] | 25/25 | Pricking cupping +B | B | 10 | T:52.4±5.3 C:51.2±3.6 | ①④ |
| Xu 2020 [23] | 30/30 | Pricking cupping +B | B | 28 | T:55.37±5.29 C:54.60±5.24 | ① |
| Wang 2020 [24] | 32/32 | Pricking cupping +B | B | 28 | T:44.25±0.17 C:45.28±0.25 | ①②③ |
| Wang 2021 [25] | 50/50 | Pricking cupping +B | B | 28 | T:61.8±2.7 C:62.4±2.6 | ① |
| Zhu 2021 [26] | 50/50 | Pricking cupping+C | C | 28 | T:51.32±2.16 C:51.29±2.12 | ①③ |
| Gou 2021 [27] | 40/40 | Pricking cupping+C | C | 20 | T:52.20±2.71 C:52.18±2.75 | ② |
| Fang 2021 [28] | 50/50 | Pricking cupping+C | C | 30 | T:53.16±1.34 C:53.34±1.31 | ① |
| Yang 2021 [29] | 42/42 | Pricking cupping+C | C | 22 | T:53.95±3.92 C:53.89±3.87 | ①② |
| Huang 2022 [30] | 36/36 | Pricking cupping+C | C | 10 | T:50.78±2.98 C:51.21±3.23 | ①③ |
| Deng 2022 [31] | 30/30 | Pricking cupping +A | A | 9 | T:60.63±6.73 C:59.3±7.97 | ①② |
| Su 2022 [32] | 50/50 | Pricking cupping+C | C | 20 | T:53.13±3.40 C:52.12±3.46 | ①② |
Note: T=Experimental group; C=Control group; ① Total Clinical effective rate; ② Pain; ③ range of motion; ④ Relapse rate; A: Electroacupuncture B: Acupuncture C: Warm acupuncture D: acupotomy