Editorial Workflow
1
Author Submission
Author submits manuscript through the online submission system. The submission is checked for completeness and adherence to journal scope.
Day 0
2
Initial Editorial Check
Editor-in-Chief or Associate Editor performs initial assessment for scope, originality, and basic quality standards.
3-5 days
3
Reviewer Assignment
Editor identifies and invites 2-3 qualified peer reviewers with relevant expertise.
3-7 days
4
Peer Review
Reviewers evaluate methodology, results, significance, and provide constructive feedback.
2-4 weeks
5
Editor Evaluation
Editor assesses reviewer comments and makes preliminary decision.
1-2 weeks
6
Final Decision
Author receives decision: Accept, Minor Revision, Major Revision, or Reject.
Total: 4-6 weeks
Editor
Decision
Decision
Accept
Manuscript accepted for publication
~15%Minor/Major Revision
Author revises and resubmits
~65%Reject
Manuscript not suitable
~20%Revision Process
1
Author Revision
Author addresses reviewer comments, prepares point-by-point response letter, and revises manuscript.
2-6 weeks
2
Revised Submission
Author submits revised manuscript and response letter through the online system.
Day 0 of revision
3
Editor Review
Editor evaluates revisions and may send back to reviewers for re-evaluation.
2-3 weeks
4
Final Decision
Editor makes final decision. Manuscript moves to production or requires further revision.
1-2 weeks
Typical Timeline
Initial Check
3-5 days
Reviewer Invitation
3-7 days
Peer Review
2-4 weeks
Editor Decision
1-2 weeks
Total to First Decision
4-6 weeks
Who's Involved?
Author
Submits original research and responds to reviewer feedback
Editor
Manages review process and makes final decision
Reviewer
Provides expert evaluation and constructive feedback